06 November 2006

What a mumsy arse you have

Check this out. Then read on. (I took out the implanted video because Blogger was having a hissy this morning.)

Oh ha ha hee hee, very funny. My old pimply mother ass is shaking its flabby booty so hard I can hardly pick my stupid high rise jeans out of the crack.

This is a Saturday Night Live sketch and I suppose therefore I ought to have a very broad (like my bottom) sense of humor about it. It is funny, but the attitude towards mothers that underlies it bugs me.

See, it pokes fun at exactly that stereotype -- mother as former woman -- that provokes a whole counterculture of hipmomhood that is equally repressive. So what if some women who are mothers wear stupid jeans? So what if some women don't? While mothers might be slightly more guilty of the unwashed ponytail look, that's from fracking necessity, bozos. It's not a fashion choice. Pre, post, mid or past giving birth, we are all different; we are all valuable and we are all unique. LL Bean would go out of business if there weren't women (like my maiden aunt) who positively LOVE their jeans to come up to their armpits.

Part of what the ad makes fun of is not just that mothers lack style, but that mothers' bodies are different and less attractive that the bodies of women who have not given birth. Well, yes, they are different. Growing human beings takes its toll on our muscles, our tendons, our skin -- indeed, our very skeletal structure changes. These are not things that all of us can successfully hide. That we seek to hide them in order to be attractive reinforces the idea that a mother's body is not attractive -- read, sexually desirable. To some extent, that might be true. As a species we might very well be programmed to respond sexually to young, fertile humans. Those of us who have already done our bit to perpetuate the species are (so goes one theory) marked by our reproductive status. Spread the genes around! Impregnate someone fresh!

I'd like to think that I am still attractive, but I do not look the same as I did. And my low rise jeans struggle to contain that flappy bit of stretched stomach skin that marks how enormous I got. My bras have to be slightly more industrial strength lest my breasts catch in my fly. My clothes are often selected more for function than brute cuteness and I can't tell you how many pairs of trousers I've worn through at the knees in the last six years.

I still struggle myself with wanting to be hip, wonderful and interesting. I hate and resent that sometimes I get shelved simply because I am a mother, that people think my interests will be limited, my conversation dull and my butt flabby. On the other hand, I don't think that I am likely to ever wear a bikini again -- and I am not about to hold that up as a goal of motherhood.

What I want is to come to a place of respect for my body and what it can do and what it has done, rather than simply for how it looks. I would love my mother body to inspire respect and love and even desire. But how my jeans fit is not a mark of how sexy I am. To find that out, you'd have to take them off. And all jeans look the same crumpled up on the floor.

NaNoWriMo thought for the day: Somewhere on the NaNoWriMo site there's a bit that says that participants are freed from housework for the month of November and that someone else has to cook the meals. That ain't gonna happen, and not because Ed's not a good guy but because he's in his own version of NaNoWriMo which is WriBloDisNo (Write the Bloody Dissertation Now). He's also away interviewing somewhere and while I'm rather too happy to give myself cereal for supper every night, I'm not up to surviving the guilt of doing that to the children. So in fact, this is rather good -- this is what being a writer would be like. Life doesn't stop. Dishes need doing and so does the laundry. And still, there must be time to write.

22 Comments:

Blogger ECR wrote...

Maybe my sense of humor went the way of my flat stomach, but I don't even find the skit funny. So I'm wondering if it's genuinely non-amusing or if the same issues you have with it are welling up in my subconscious and taking the fun out of it for me?

6/11/06 18:11  
Blogger Karen Rani wrote...

"my low rise jeans struggle to contain that flappy bit of stretched stomach skin that marks how enormous I got."

I got it too - it's called a muffin top! Daren laughs because he'll hug me (sticking his hands up my shirt) and I'll say "Don't play with the muffin top!" and he'll shoot back, "Can I play with your muffin?"

I love that skit - but then, I don't wear the "Mom Jeans." :D Because muffin tops are SO much more attractive. Heh.

6/11/06 18:24  
Blogger The Purloined Letter wrote...

I'm with Ed: around here it is FiGoDaBoAsSoAsPo (Finish God Damned Book As Soon as Possible) although I did not realize it had a name until just now. And I've been working under this and other similar deadlines for so many years that I'm still wearing my jeans from when highrise jeans were is fashion.... (The fact that I NEVER had the sexy young thing body meant that my body honestly did not change that much after pregnancy.)

6/11/06 18:56  
Blogger Pauline wrote...

Your comments were funnier than the skit! At 60, I have given up being a sex symbol and have gone for the comfortable look. It's a LOT more comfortable than low rise jeans on a high rise figure :)

6/11/06 19:27  
Anonymous cheesefairy wrote...

Just nablopomo-randomizer'd to your site..I haven't worn highrise jeans since I got my navel pierced 10 years ago (the piercing has since been removed) and now just find them too uncomfortable, but I definitely have mom hair and mom boobs. And a muffintop. And a 4-month old, so I don't really give a damn.

You said: "What I want is to come to a place of respect for my body and what it can do and what it has done, rather than simply for how it looks." I heartily concur & hope you do come to that place - hope we all do.

6/11/06 20:01  
Blogger venessa wrote...

I'd like to think that being a mom has put me in a position to no longer be "sex object" and just be "human." But then I see guys wearing shirts that say "I Love Hot Moms." So I don't know if I'll ever get to that point in life. Hmm.

By the way, thanks for stopping by my blog!

6/11/06 22:17  
Anonymous Momish wrote...

Very well put! I agree with all your points and struggle with the same issues. However, I sometimes feel lucky that I had my child at a late age (38) with regards to how I feel about my body. I already saw the toll age alone was taking on me physically. It seems easier to come to grips with that rather than just having a baby. I don't know why, maybe because everyone ages so it's more a universal thing? Anyway, I have the flabby tummy (I call it my Piper Pouch), so I hear ya!

Great post!

6/11/06 22:21  
Anonymous krista wrote...

I think the skit is hilarious. I couldn't stop smiling throughout the thing. But what I love more is that You Don't- and you are so eloquent and wonderful in your deconstruction of it.

6/11/06 22:34  
Anonymous krista wrote...

Oh, and I also love your NaNoWriMo thought for the day. Keep it real.

6/11/06 22:35  
Blogger Jen wrote...

It's such a trick bag for me--I want nothing more than to be a person rather than a body, but I still look at my stretch marks and muffin top and wonder if I'll ever look in the mirror and say, 'damn, you're hot.' Of course, I never did that before having a kid.
I've finally gotten to the point, though, where I resent the hell out of feeling like there is some sort of hotness standard. I am what I am, same as I ever was, no matter how my body has changed. Either people think it's hot or don't, but I can't lose any more sleep over that. It almost feels as though after going through the remarkable strength that childbirth requires, women have to prove that they are still capable of sexiness, when I feel that strength should be an inherent part of attractiveness. Sorry for writing a book here :)

7/11/06 00:07  
Blogger karrie wrote...

What Krista said. I love SNL, even when it lacks taste. :)

I'm such an odd, apple-y shape that moderately lowrise jeans are the only ones I can wear.

bellies+lowrise+snl=more cowbell!

7/11/06 06:53  
Blogger Mighty Momogus wrote...

Like Momish, I had my son late too (38), and while it made the physical part of motherhood tougher since I simply didn't have the same energy that I did 10 years earlier, it made the mental part much easier for me. I had sown A LOT of wild oats in those 38 years and was glad to be off the market/on the shelf/out of contention, whatever.

It helps to have a partner who endorses how you look now rather than carping on how you used to look. I have a friend who weighs approximately 2 pounds, even after 2 kids. Her husband poked her in the (practically non-existent) belly one day and said, "What are you going to do about this?" Can you imagine living with someone like that??

7/11/06 07:19  
Blogger eyeknit wrote...

Hey, are you ripping on my L.L. Bean jeans? Low-rise jeans have never suited me, even before the little man arrived.

7/11/06 12:15  
Anonymous Anonymous wrote...

This skit was hilarious. I hope you'll be able to lighten up soon. Lots of women get into ranting and raving about how "society" makes them feel about their bodies, when really they are the only ones who can create those feelings for themselves. The skit was clearly poking fun at the creator's own insecurities while triggering yours as well.

Years ago, an anthropological study of African tribes showed that the men found the women who were already mothers more sexually attractive, with their large bums and breasts like deflated balloons, while the young girls seemed "unfinished" to them. These physical qualities of the mothers indicated fertility, because they had the children to prove it.

7/11/06 15:29  
Blogger Masked Mom wrote...

Listen--I think the most excellent point was: "But how my jeans fit is not a mark of how sexy I am. To find that out, you'd have to take them off. And all jeans look the same crumpled up on the floor." For which you have my hearty thanks and an "amen!"

7/11/06 18:00  
Anonymous Smarterthananonymous wrote...

I read in an article in a magazine I may have found in a hedge once that people who post comments on blogs anonymously have 20 percent smaller brains than average which helps to explain why they think they're smarter than everyone else because in fact they really don't get it. Also hello.

This comment has 50 percent more cowbell than the ridiculous comment by 'anonymous' (which I could prove by reference to vague and spurious sources only I don't have time right now). So Mr. Anonymous (and yes, you must assuredly be male from your "lots of women..."), thank you for bringing the reputation of our shared gender a little lower. Come back and comment again when you grow a pair and are ready to take ownership of your opinions by attaching some identity to them. On second thoughts, don't.

This post is 27% ironic as measured by a survey of Andea noseflute virtuosi to be published in a magazine coming to a hedge near you soon.

7/11/06 19:52  
Anonymous n.b. wrote...

I thought the skit was amusing in some ways: I think it was really meant to poke fun at the pretty unappealing fashions sold through JCPenney. I kind of liked the prancing and grinning Moms. But yeah, the unintentional "side victims" are us Moms who now look like that, or even WISH we looked like that (where were the size sixteen in that ad I ask you?) We wish we looked different because we live, of course, in a youth culture. Yeah, we are part of that very culture, but that doesn't mean we aren't allowed to feel bad about it when it hurts us. Most 50 and 60 year olds I know have gone through this "mourning period" and are now done with it. Seems to be a 30 and 40 year old thing.

7/11/06 22:58  
Blogger KatieK wrote...

Actually the women in the ad were all quite fit and attractive.They also look very healthy, and very happy. Their jeans were merely four inches too long in the waist. What's the problem? Haven't middle aged people always been out of it? Isn't that the point of the generation gap? Haven't younger people always poked fun at their parents? Do women really have to be pantingly sexy and cutting edge fashionable forever and ever? Whatever happened to just being human and living and getting on with things? I live in Turkey. While I don't find Islam interesting in the least, I sometimes think it would be easier if we just put everything under a big black bag and forgot about it.

8/11/06 09:53  
Anonymous Andrea wrote...

I blogged about this a month or so ago--that if "being a mom" were really this status symbol thing where we are all expected to procreate because it's cool, which is the message I keep hearing, then "mom jeans" would be a fabulously cool fashion item, not an object of ridicule and contempt.

So yeah. I'm with you.

8/11/06 10:51  
Blogger Rima wrote...

Amen sistah! I found that sketch offensive when it first aired, but I'm slightly amused at the idea that some of them have since had babies.

8/11/06 19:57  
Blogger Stuntmother wrote...

Thanks for all your comments. I really enjoyed the wide variety of reactions to this post. I loved that Krista and Karrie both liked it -- and didn't call me a fool for not liking it (thanks ;)). I was also interested in those comments which said that having babies later made the body change issues easier. I have wondered about that myself, whether the changes I see in myself are post motherhood or just encroaching old age. But that's a post to come some other day. I am thrilled to know that there is a name for my strange stomach -- and that Momish named hers! I wonder what I would name mine... Muffin Top Pouch of Procreative Doom, perhaps. Jen, come write a book anytime -- I thought your comment was wonderful -- thoughtful and real. NB, I completely agree that there is also a piece of this which is a youth worshipping culture issue -- and there is a blog post to come about what I fondly imagine is the freedom past the mourning period of the end of anything that could ever be called youth. KatieK, I think I agree. Or at least, I definitely agree that what I would really like to see happen is what you describe, that we can live and be people and let others just be. On the other hand (after six years in Egypt) I find Islam tremendously fascinating, in part its issues about women's bodies and how they should be covered. The burka doesn't seem to resolve the body issue -- then there's a whole culture of what you're wearing under the damn black bag.

(And you can imagine how much I like the second anonymous posting which nearly made me spray my coffee. Thirty percent of pygmies interviewed by a lemming agreed that studies can prove pretty much anything the researcher wants them to prove.)

But the comment that made me want to leap out and grab the commenter by the arm and drag her out for coffee and ranting was Andrea's...YES YES YES! If being a mom were all that, then EVERYONE would want to wear Mom jeans. Oh yeah, baby.

Oh, and I have no plans to lighten up, ever. Take that you fiend! And that! Hieeee-ya! I slay you with my intensity!

8/11/06 22:59  
Anonymous Andrea wrote...

Anytime you're in the TO area, feel free to drag me out for coffee and ranting. Even though I don't drink coffee. I still think it would be fun.

9/11/06 18:09  

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home